Network meta-analysis (NMA) draws conclusions about indirect comparisons of randomized clinical trials and is considered high-level evidence. Most NMA publications make use of network plots to portray results. Network plots are complex graphics that can have many visual attributes to portray useful information, such as node size, color, and graph layout. We analyzed the network plots from 162 NMAs of systemic anticancer therapy efficacy using a set of 16 attributes. Our review showed that the current state of network plot data visualizations within the NMA space lacks diversity and does not make use of many of the visual attributes available to convey information. More thoughtful design choices should be placed behind these important visualizations, which can carry clinical significance and help derive treatment plans for patients.